Two teenage boys, Ethan and Sean, decide to pull the prank of the decade on their old, grumpy neighbor Harold. One morning when the old man leaves his home, the two boys get inside his house and set up cameras and equipment that will help them simulate a haunting. Yup, they’re going to trick Harold into thinking his house is haunted! It’s supposed to also be the basis for a school project, where the “experiment“ will give them insight in a person’s unfiltered reaction to experiencing a haunting. And yes, these are teenage boys, and teens do all kinds of stupid shit for all kinds of stupid reasons, but…it doesn’t require more than a sliver of common sense to understand that what they’re doing isn’t only illegal, but highly immoral. So when these very tech-savvy kids keep monitoring their old neighbor’s home through their hidden cameras, you don’t exactly root for them.
Now, first of all they decide to play it small by making a kitchen door bang loudly in the middle of the night. Harold’s reaction to this is…not what they expected, to say the least. As they continue their experiment, they also notice something that really peaks their curiosity, especially Ethan’s. The cellar door, which was bolted and locked when they entered the house (which caused some frustration since they would not be able to place any cameras or equipment there) is suddenly opened by Harold in the middle of the night. And after going down there, he’s spending hours until he gets back up. What’s in that cellar? And why is Harold acting so…strange, to say the least, when faced with what he surely must think is some kind of supernatural phenomena?
The Good Neighbor is a thriller from 2016, directed by Kasra Farahani and written by Mark Bianculli and Jeff Richard. It’s a mystery-fueled story which is actually pretty simple, but also suspenseful and entertaining. Two teenage boys playing a prank on their grumpy neighbor by using illegal means, what could possibly go wrong!
Harold, played by James Caan, really comes off as your typical grouchy “get off my laaawn!“ type of neighbor. Kind of like Nebbercracker in Monster House. There’s even a scene where he’s threatening to kill some guy’s dog after it urinated on his property. Yikes…and just like we can’t really be on the teenagers side as what they’re doing is wrong on so many levels, there’s not much sympathy to be had for Harold in the start of the movie either. He just seems like a crabby, miserable piece of shit. Then, of course, you wonder if he’s got reasons for being the way he is, just like Nebbercracker…
There were multiple times where I was fairly certain where this was headed, and I guess that’s a little because the movie sometimes certainly nudged you in that direction, but there were one surprise after the other which made the mystery fairly compelling. Needless to say, there are of course more layers to the characters and their motives and personalities, and since the movie often breaks into short segments from present time where we’re witnessing a trial, we know early on that things really went bad in some kind of way.
The Good Neighbor is one of those films where it’s best to go in without knowing much. Definitely a suspenseful thriller which keeps you guessing, and may take different turns than you expected.
Director: Kasra Farahani
Writers: Mark Bianculli, Jeff Richard
Country & year: USA, 2016
Actors: James Caan, Logan Miller, Keir Gilchrist, Laura Innes, Edwin Hodge, Bailey Noble, Lili Reinhart, Anne Dudek, Mindy Sterling, William Charles Mitchell
IMDb: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2262315/
![]()




















